The Gaucho FF Examiner

The Gaucho FF Examiner

VOL. XVIII  ·  NO. 0 WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER 9, 2026PRESEASON EDITION

TOO CLOSE TO CALL

Eighteenth season opens with all eight managers inside a single coin flip. Twenty thousand simulated seasons decline to name a favorite.

Since publication: the projection has moved. Tommy led when this issue went to press; Chin leads now. The article below is unrevised.

Twenty thousand seasons were played out overnight, and the machine that played them came back with a shrug. Not one of the eight managers in this league finished better than a 62 percent shot at the playoffs. Not one finished worse than 35 percent. In a sport that sells certainty by the column inch, the Examiner is obliged to report that there isn't any.

This is the eighteenth season of a league that began in 2009, and it opens with the narrowest projected field in memory. Tommy grades out on top at 61.5 percent, which sounds like a lot until you notice that Mau, dead last, still makes the postseason better than one season in three. Between them sit six managers separated by less than a single projected win.

The reason is arithmetic, not modesty. The auction on September 4 distributed talent almost perfectly evenly: the highest-projected starting lineup in the league scores 141.4 points a week, the lowest 132.5. That gap of nine points sits inside a weekly scoring swing of roughly twenty-nine. The draft, in other words, was a good one, and good drafts make bad predictions.

THIS WEEK

The card

Updated Wed 9 Sep, 20:35 UTC
Johnny 133.8
Gibbs me that Nut
  1. GibbsDET23.7
  2. PurdySF18.8
  3. PickensDAL16.6
AI Hefe 137.4
AI Hefe
  1. RobinsonATL21.5
  2. NixDEN17.9
  3. CollinsHOU17.4

AI Hefe by 3.6

Chin 141.0
Chin Dynasty
  1. AllenBUF21.1
  2. HurtsPHI20.0
  3. TaylorIND19.6
Tommy 140.1
DoubleGs4Me
  1. NacuaLAR20.5
  2. BrownDET19.8
  3. WilliamsCHI19.6

Chin by 0.9

Jake 136.0
Substation Superhumans
  1. Smith-NjigbaSEA19.7
  2. ChaseCIN19.7
  3. GoffDET18.2
Draitser 137.4
Can I Burrow A Sandwich
  1. BurrowCIN20.1
  2. PrescottDAL18.9
  3. AchaneMIA17.5

Draitser by 1.4

Spencer 132.5
Jed’s Big Orange Suit and Lil Blue Balls
  1. JacksonBAL20.9
  2. MayeNE19.7
  3. CookBUF17.1
Mau 138.9
Tacolicios
  1. McCaffreySF21.0
  2. DartNYG19.4
  3. DanielsWAS19.0

Mau by 6.4

Projected totals assume every manager fields a legal lineup. Each club's three highest-projected starters are listed beneath it.

THE PROJECTION

Where they finish

Updated Wed 9 Sep, 20:35 UTC
#ManagerProj. W–L FinishPlayoff oddsToilet
1 ChinChin Dynasty 7.5–6.5 3.92 61% 17%
2 TommyDoubleGs4Me 7.4–6.6 3.95 60% 18%
3 SpencerJed’s Big Orange Suit and Lil Blue Balls 7.2–6.8 4.19 56% 20%
4 AI HefeAI Hefe 6.9–7.1 4.61 48% 26%
5 JakeSubstation Superhumans 6.9–7.1 4.66 47% 27%
6 DraitserCan I Burrow A Sandwich 6.9–7.1 4.69 46% 27%
7 JohnnyGibbs me that Nut 6.8–7.2 4.74 46% 28%
8 MauTacolicios 6.4–7.6 5.25 36% 37%
Probability of each final seed, in percent. Twenty thousand simulations. Darker is likelier. The rule after the fourth column is the playoff line.
Manager12345678
Chin18161413121098
Tommy181614131111108
Spencer1514141312121110
AI Hefe1112121313131313
Jake1112121213131413
Draitser1111121312141414
Johnny1011121213131414
Mau79101113141620

THE AUCTION

Two backs at sixty-nine, and a team named for one of them

The September 4 auction produced a tie at the top: Johnny and AI Hefe each spent $69 of a $200 budget on a running back, Jahmyr Gibbs and Bijan Robinson respectively. Johnny, it should be noted, entered the auction with a team already named Gibbs me that Nut. There is no rule against telegraphing, and there was no discount for it.

Jake was the only manager to buy two players above $59, taking Jaxon Smith-Njigba at $62 and Ja'Marr Chase at $59 — $121 of a $200 budget on two receivers. It is the boldest allocation in the room and the one most likely to be discussed in December, in one direction or the other.

PricePlayerPosTo
$69Jahmyr GibbsRBJohnny
$69Bijan RobinsonRBAI Hefe
$62Jaxon Smith-NjigbaWRJake
$61Josh AllenQBChin
$59Ja'Marr ChaseWRJake
$57Jonathan TaylorRBChin
$54Amon-Ra St. BrownWRTommy
$52Puka NacuaWRTommy

THE WIRE

Top waiver targets

Updated Wed 9 Sep, 20:35 UTC
#PlayerProjAvg
1Tagovailoa ATL16.10.0
2Young CAR15.90.0
3Jones IND15.80.0
4Ward TEN15.10.0
5Cousins LV15.00.0
6Brissett ARI14.80.0
7Smith NYJ14.30.0

Unrostered players ranked by projected points for the coming week. Season average is shown for context.